Skip to main content

come in, we’re open

Local Nantucket pickup and delivery options available in checkout.

Ope! Nothing to see here.

    • Market
    • /
    • "The Finback" - Mystic Cheese
    • "The Finback" - Mystic Cheese
    • Market
    • /
    • "The Finback" - Mystic Cheese

    Mystic Cheese

    "The Finback" - Mystic Cheese


    The Finback is Cheddar-like but much more complex. You can taste flavors of cooked milk, browned butter, savory stock, and stone fruit on the finish. Be sure to eat the rind. It is more than edible… it’s delicious! Mystic Cheese sources their milk from a single herd on a neighboring farm in Groton, CT.  Pair with honey and apples. 

    avg. 5oz cuts 

    Available for pickup & delivery!

    Hand-picked for you (literally and figuratively)

    Our Values

    • Local

      We believe supporting local builds a stronger community. We collectively support friends, neighbors, and colleagues to make and grow the things they love. In doing so, we get fresh goods made with care and we support a thriving local economy.

    • Seasonal

      Seasons change fast in New England and we are committed to only selling what is available locally. We believe seasonal eating supports our farmers and connects us to place. When you buy from our market, you know you are eating in season.

    • Simple

      Small farmers and small producers struggle to connect to you, the consumer. We want shopping local and supporting our neighbors to be easy and we believe Pip & Anchor does just that. All local, all season, all in one place.

    14 Amelia Drive, Nantucket Massachusetts

    Visit our brick & mortar location

    Stop by for crafted espresso drinks, delicious casual lunch options, and so much more.

    9am - 6pm Tuesday - Saturday

    9am - 2pm on Sunday

    Closed Monday



    A pip up for your feed